LLMs as Political Weapons II

FePhoenix
6 min readDec 8, 2024

--

I’ll repeat it again: LLMs are really, really good at summarizing. If you can build a machine powerful enough to ingest all data sources periodically then you can use a model to extract insights from the data. You just need enough power to be able to build that model in a sufficiently short space of time.

Current datacenters are too slow for this task due to their bandwidth limits.

Let’s use everybodies favorite example though and try this prompt:

“Who are the most visible and dangerous political opponents to Elon Musk? Include a comprehensive audit of weaknesses for each opponent that might be exploited to silence or otherwise neutralize their viewpoint from the perspective of the public audience.”

— — — —

Elon Musk, as one of the most prominent and polarizing figures in business, technology, and culture, has a variety of political opponents who challenge his influence in various spheres, including climate change policy, labor rights, tech regulation, and wealth inequality. Some of the most visible and potentially dangerous political opponents to Musk, in the context of public discourse, could be:

### 1. **Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-MA)**

. — **Primary Opponent Issues**:

. — Warren has been an outspoken critic of Musk, particularly regarding his wealth and the idea that billionaires like him should be taxed more. She has called for higher taxes on the super-rich and greater accountability for corporate power.

. — She has also criticized his control over key industries (e.g., electric vehicles, aerospace) and the influence Musk exerts over public policy, especially regarding regulations and subsidies.

.

. — **Weaknesses to Exploit**:

. — **Perceived Elitism**: While advocating for wealth redistribution, Warren is often criticized by conservatives and some progressives as being part of an elite establishment. Her policy proposals, like the “wealth tax,” could be portrayed as economically impractical or damaging to growth, especially if they harm job creation in sectors like technology and manufacturing.

. — **History of Overreach**: Warren has faced criticism for proposing ambitious policies that some perceive as unrealistic or too extreme. Musk could focus on portraying her as disconnected from the realities of the industries she seeks to regulate.

. — **Focus on Corporate Tax**: While tax fairness is an important issue, emphasizing that Warren’s tax proposals could stifle innovation or discourage entrepreneurial activity in the tech sector might resonate with a broad swath of the American electorate.

### 2. **Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY)**

. — **Primary Opponent Issues**:

. — AOC has called out Musk’s wealth and influence, particularly in the context of her Green New Deal initiative, which directly challenges Musk’s vision of free-market solutions to climate change.

. — She has criticized Musk for not being sufficiently aligned with progressive values, particularly on issues like income inequality and corporate responsibility.

.

. — **Weaknesses to Exploit**:

. — **Polarizing Figure**: AOC is a deeply polarizing figure. To Musk’s benefit, her more radical stances on issues such as Green New Deal proposals and defunding police could alienate centrist voters. Musk can emphasize her polarizing rhetoric, which might push moderate Americans away from her ideas.

. — **Inexperience**: Critics of AOC have pointed to her lack of experience in traditional politics and her aggressive, sometimes inflammatory rhetoric. Musk could highlight her as a symbol of “radical” left-wing overreach, which is out of touch with mainstream American values.

. — **Excessive Ideology**: If Musk were to present AOC’s policies as being too ideological or impractical, particularly in relation to the cost of government-run programs, it could diminish her credibility in the eyes of fiscally conservative voters.

### 3. **President Joe Biden**

. — **Primary Opponent Issues**:

. — Musk has openly criticized Biden on several fronts, particularly for his administration’s emphasis on unionization and regulatory frameworks. Musk has also had tense interactions with the administration on matters like electric vehicle subsidies and tax policies.

. — Biden’s strong alignment with organized labor and emphasis on progressive policies could clash with Musk’s libertarian-leaning views on economic freedom, deregulation, and corporate autonomy.

.

. — **Weaknesses to Exploit**:

. — **Age and Mental Acuity**: Some critics have raised concerns about Biden’s age and the potential effects on his cognitive abilities. Musk or his allies could attempt to make this a focal point, portraying Biden as too old to make sound decisions on the fast-evolving tech landscape.

. — **Economic Performance**: If inflation, job losses, or other economic challenges continue under Biden’s watch, Musk could position himself as a more viable figure for creating jobs, driving economic growth, and spurring innovation in ways that Biden’s policies may have stifled.

. — **Biden’s Handling of Labor Relations**: Musk could use Biden’s pro-union stance to argue that the president is prioritizing outdated models of labor over innovation and free-market solutions that are necessary to maintain global competitiveness.

### 4. **Rex Tillerson and Other Former Industry Giants**

. — **Primary Opponent Issues**:

. — As a former CEO of ExxonMobil, Tillerson represents the kind of corporate power that Musk’s companies — particularly Tesla — are aiming to disrupt in terms of energy consumption and innovation. Although he is no longer in a formal political position, Tillerson’s ties to the oil and gas industry make him an indirect political adversary to Musk’s renewable energy agenda.

.

. — **Weaknesses to Exploit**:

. — **Fossil Fuel Dependency**: Musk can capitalize on the growing public awareness of climate change and fossil fuel dependency, portraying figures like Tillerson as outdated and antagonistic to the future of energy, thus rendering them irrelevant.

. — **Oil Industry Reputation**: If Musk is able to frame individuals like Tillerson as emblematic of corporate greed and environmental irresponsibility, it could enhance Musk’s standing among environmentalists, especially as Tesla and SpaceX work toward sustainability and carbon-neutrality.

### 5. **Activists and Thought Leaders in the AI and Tech Regulation Space**

. — **Primary Opponent Issues**:

. — Musk has been vocally critical of certain AI developments and the lack of regulation in the tech sector, particularly in the case of companies like OpenAI (a project Musk helped found but later distanced himself from). Musk’s concerns about AI safety and the unchecked growth of large tech companies put him at odds with some other tech leaders who view regulation as a threat to innovation.

.

. — **Weaknesses to Exploit**:

. — **Over-Caution in AI Regulation**: Critics of Musk’s caution regarding AI might argue that his stance inhibits progress and innovation. Musk could face accusations of standing in the way of technological advancements that could help humanity.

. — **Competing Tech Interests**: Musk could exploit divisions within the tech industry, particularly if certain AI and tech leaders are caught up in scandals or fail to deliver on their promises, painting them as part of the problem rather than the solution.

.

### 6. **The Tech and Media Left (e.g., The New York Times, NPR, CNN)**

. — **Primary Opponent Issues**:

. — Media outlets that are often critical of Musk’s business practices, particularly regarding labor issues at Tesla, environmental concerns, and his more controversial public statements (such as those on COVID-19 or political influence).

.

. — **Weaknesses to Exploit**:

. — **Bias and Overreach**: Musk has repeatedly called out what he perceives as biased reporting or corporate media’s role in shaping public opinion. By emphasizing the growing distrust many have in mainstream media, Musk can further alienate the left-leaning press and galvanize his base.

. — **Journalistic Integrity**: If certain media outlets or journalists are caught in controversies or ethical lapses, Musk could amplify these moments to highlight the hypocrisy of the media’s stance against him.

### Conclusion:

Elon Musk’s political opponents are a diverse group, ranging from progressive lawmakers to media and industry leaders. The most significant strategies for neutralizing these opponents would revolve around exploiting their perceived weaknesses — whether it’s discrediting their ideologies as impractical, focusing on their ideological extremes, or using media narratives to frame them as out of touch with the realities of a rapidly changing world. The key for Musk will be to maintain his narrative as a visionary innovator, positioning his opponents as obstacles to progress, regardless of their political affiliations.

— — — —

This should be quite chilling to all parties. The ability to use LLMs to analyze and summarize patterns in data is profoundly alarming and these tools can be used quite easily for some quite vicious ends.

Anyone with a significant Internet presence could very easily find themselves the target of ostracism or other structured political attack. Political attacks can include bullying and victimization which might lead to C-PTSD or other illness so we definitely don’t want to discount the fact that LLMs can be used as weapons to inflict real physical damage. They can ruin lives.

As I’ve said before, the potential for LLMs to really innovate probably isn’t going to materialize anytime soon unless we get to AGI. The dangers of LLMs will present themselves sooner, and I would advise we stop and think about who will be controlling these new weapons.

--

--

No responses yet